巅峰时期的姚明和现在的约基奇，谁会更强一些？

这是一个非常有趣的话题，自从NBA球队丹佛掘金进入季后赛以后，中国的篮球迷就开始广泛的讨论这个问题，虎扑上关于这个问题的讨论，至少有成千上万个回复，全球支持姚明和约基奇的球迷唇枪舌剑，各不相让，甚至把两人的数据都分列出来进行一一对应，逐项分析，一直到丹佛掘金夺冠以后，相关的讨论才逐渐的平息下来。

正好最近在接触和了解人工智能，OpenAI的Chat GPT和Google的Bard应该是AI界的两大顶流产品，国内朋友听说Chat GPT的比较多， 接触Bard的应该比较少，Bard是Google类似于Chat GPT的大模型人工智能产品

当年OpenAI的Chat GPT横空出世的时候，Google内部直接拉响了红色警报，奋起直追，很快推出的人工智能产品就是Bard，GPT和Bard的竞争，直接导致科技界的硬件竞争白热化，人工智能芯片NVIDIA的产品价格暴涨，股票市值破万亿美金…………….

不扯那么远了，那么，如果把这个有意思的问题问一下ChatGPT和Bard，分别会得到什么答案呢？哈哈，歪瑞英吹斯汀………..

我们先来看ChatGPT，ChatGPT的回答一如既往的中庸

问题1：姚明和约基奇谁更厉害?

ChatGPT的回答：

姚明和约基奇是两位非常出色的篮球运动员，他们在各自的职业生涯中都取得了惊人的成就。姚明在NBA效力期间曾多次入选全明星阵容，被誉为中国篮球的象征，他的身高和技术使他成为一名强大的中锋球员。

约基奇则是NBA历史上最全能的中锋之一，他能够在得分、篮板和助攻等多个方面表现出色。

对于谁更厉害，很难做出明确的判断，因为这涉及个人偏好和不同的评判标准。无论如何，姚明和约基奇都是伟大的球员，他们的才华和成就都值得赞赏。

问题2：Can Yao Ming Beat Yokic? 姚明能打爆约基奇吗？

ChatGPT的回答：

Its difficult to say definitively without more context. If youre asking whether Yao Ming, the retired Chinese basketball player, could beat Nikola Jokic, the current Serbian basketball player, in a one-on-one game, its impossible to know for sure since they have never played against each other and there are many variables that could affect the outcome. However, both players are highly skilled and accomplished in their respective eras, so it would likely be a close and competitive matchup regardless of the outcome.

如果没有更多的背景，很难确定地说。如果你是在问退役的中国篮球运动员姚明能否在一对一的比赛中击败现任塞尔维亚篮球运动员尼古拉·乔基奇(Nikola Jokic)，那就不可能确定。

因为他们从来没有一起打过比赛，而且有很多变量可能会影响结果。然而，这两位球员在各自的时代都是高技能和有成就的，所以无论结果如何，这都可能是一场势均力敌的比赛。

CHAT-GPT的结论：

GPT含含糊糊一如既往的以中国人典型含蓄的方式，乖巧的给出了你好我好大家好的答案，两个都很强，不太好比较，就这样吧……..看上去说了一大堆，其实啥也没说………..哇哈哈

我们再来看一下Google人工智能Bard的回答

问题1：姚明和约基奇谁更厉害?

BARD的回答：

Yao Ming and Nikola Jokic are two of the most dominant centers in NBA history. Yao was a 76″ giant with a soft touch around the basket, while Jokic is a 611″ playmaker who can score from anywhere on the court.

If these two players were to face off in a one-on-one game, it would be a close contest. Yao has the size advantage, but Jokic has the agility and quickness. Jokic would also have the advantage from long range, as he is a better shooter than Yao.

Ultimately, the winner of the game would likely come down to who could impose their will on the other player. If Yao could get Jokic in the post, he would have a good chance of scoring. However, if Jokic could stay out of the post and use his quickness to his advantage, he would likely be able to score more points.

In my opinion, Jokic would win the one-on-one game. He is a more skilled player than Yao and he has the advantage in terms of agility and quickness. However, it would be a close contest and Yao would certainly have a chance to win.

Here is a table that summarizes the strengths and weaknesses of each player:

姚明和约基奇是NBA历史上最具统治力的两位中锋。姚是一个7尺6寸的巨人，在篮下有一个柔软的触球，而约基奇是一个6尺11寸的组织核心，在场上任何地方都能得分。

如果这两名球员在一对一的比赛中对决，那将是一场势均力敌的比赛。姚有体型优势，但约基奇有敏捷。约基奇在远距离也有优势，因为他是一个比姚更好的射手。

最终，比赛的获胜者很可能取决于谁可以将自己的优势发挥出来。如果姚能限制约基奇在篮筐下，他就很有机会得分。然而，如果约基奇能够远离篮筐下，利用他的快速优势，约基奇很可能会得到更多的分数。

在我看来，约基奇会赢得这场一对一的比赛。他是一个比姚技巧更全面和熟练的球员，他在敏捷和快速方面有优势。然而，这将是一场势均力敌的比赛，姚肯定有机会获胜。

下面是一张表格，总结了每个玩家的优势和劣势：（表格就不翻译了）

问题2：最强的姚明1V1能打爆现在的约基奇吗？

Can the most powerful Yao Ming beat the current Yokic in 1V1 game ?

BARD的回答：

It is difficult to say for sure who would win in a 1v1 game between the most powerful Yao Ming and the current Nikola Jokic. Both players are incredibly talented and skilled, and they have different strengths and weaknesses.

Yao Ming was a dominant force in the paint, with a height and wingspan that gave him a significant advantage over most opponents. He was also a very good shooter, and he could score from all over the court. However, he was not as mobile as some other centers, and he could be slow to react on defense.

Nikola Jokic is a more versatile player than Yao Ming. He is a very good passer and ball-handler, and he can score from inside and outside. He is also a very good rebounder, and he is a better defender than Yao Ming. However, he is not as physically imposing as Yao Ming, and he may not be able to match Yao Mings strength and power in the post.

Ultimately, the winner of a 1v1 game between Yao Ming and Nikola Jokic would likely come down to who was able to exploit their opponents weaknesses. If Yao Ming could get Jokic into the post, he would have a good chance of winning. However, if Jokic could keep Yao Ming out of the paint and force him to shoot from the perimeter, he would have a better chance of winning.

It is also worth noting that Yao Ming retired from the NBA in 2011, while Nikola Jokic is still playing at a high level. This means that Jokic would have the benefit of youth and experience in a 1v1 game.

Overall, it is a close call, but I would give the edge to Nikola Jokic in a 1v1 game against the most powerful Yao Ming. Jokic is a more versatile player, and he has the benefit of youth and experience. However, Yao Ming was a dominant force in his prime, and he would be a tough opponent for anyone.

最强的姚明和现任的尼古拉·约基奇之间的一对一比赛，很难说谁会获胜。 两位球员都非常有天赋和技术，他们有不同的优点和缺点。

姚明是油漆区的统治者，他的身高和臂展使他比大多数对手具有显着的优势。他也是一名非常出色的射手，他可以在球场的各个角落得分。然而，他的机动性不如其他中锋，而且他在防守上的反应可能很慢。

尼古拉·约基奇是一位比姚明更加多才多艺的球员。他是一个非常好的传球手和控球手，他可以从内线和外线得分。他也是一个非常好的篮板手，而且他的防守能力比姚明更好。不过，他的身体气势不如姚明，在内线的力量和爆发力上他也未必能比得上姚明。

最终，姚明和尼古拉·约基奇之间的一对一比赛的胜利者很可能取决于谁能够利用对手的弱点。如果姚明能进入内线，他就有很大的胜算。不过，如果约基奇能够将姚明挡在禁区之外，迫使他在外线投篮，那么约基奇获胜的机会就会更大。

另外值得注意的是，姚明在2011年从NBA退役，而尼古拉·约基奇仍然保持着高水平的发挥。这意味着约基奇在1v1比赛中将受益于年轻和经验。

总的来说，这是一场千钧一发的比赛，但我认为尼古拉·约基奇在与最强大的姚明的 1v1 比赛中具有优势。约基奇是一名更加全能的球员，他拥有年轻和经验的优势。然而，巅峰时期的姚明是统治者，对任何人来说他都是一个难对付的对手。

Bard的结论：

总体来说，Bard也很圆滑，比较客观，整体比GPT分析的更加全面，而且对双方的优势和特点都进行了总结和分析，最终得出了肯定的结论，约基奇比姚明更强一些。

这个结论，跟虎扑上大部分篮球爱好者的意见和结论是趋于一致的。

感觉Bard的思维方式更接近人类，当然这个可能也与Bard在持续更新和不断进化，GPT也许不是最新版有关系。

巅峰姚明能打爆约基奇吗？这个话题有点像关公战秦琼，也许人类没有答案，也许人工智能会有答案…………..

非常有意思的话题，加个关注，有机会再一起探讨探讨